UT Southwestern Medical Center researchers have unlocked some of the mysteries of West Nile virus outbreaks and shown that use of a mosquito vector-index rating system works well to identify the best time for early intervention.
West Nile infections in humans can cause long-term neurological damage and even death. The investigation analyzed a decade of West Nile infections, weather, and housing data. The 2012 data – from the nation’s largest West Nile outbreak that occurred in Dallas County, Texas – revealed that the best way to avoid an outbreak and stave off the resultant rise in human infections was to determine a mosquito vector index. The vector index value is calculated from the abundance of mosquitoes and the percentage of mosquitoes infected with West Nile virus.
“When the vector index goes above 0.5 early – in June or July – large numbers of people are silently infected, and this is the best time to intervene,” says Robert Haley, chief of epidemiology and professor of internal medicine at UT Southwestern and senior author of the study published in the July 17 edition of the Journal of the American Medical Association. “In years when the vector index did not rise until late July or August, impending outbreaks just sputtered – in late summer mosquito abundance declines, and mosquitoes become less active and stop biting as much.”
The study also showed that determining the number of West Nile virus infections in people is a poor way to determine how to respond to an outbreak.
“After the infecting mosquito bite, it takes a week for the first symptoms to develop, a week to see people turning up at hospitals, and a week for laboratory confirmation of the diagnosis and reporting to health officials,” Haley says. “That three-week time period is crucial. Acting early from the vector index rather than after human case reports and deaths mount up can nip an outbreak in the bud. However, if mosquito data are unavailable or a decision to intervene takes longer, later intervention may still be important to terminate the outbreak.”
The analysis also found that milder winters and unusually warm spring temperatures contributed to epidemic years for West Nile, a major concern as global temperatures continue to warm, Dr. Haley said.
A fourth critical finding in the paper related census track data to the 2012 outbreak, demonstrating that areas of higher property values, housing density, and percentages of unoccupied homes were at greater risk. The researchers said that this result is likely due to fostering the types of environment and mosquitos most likely to transmit the disease, which is carried more by house mosquitoes than forest mosquitoes. In Dallas County, their data showed year after year clustering in the Park Cities and North Dallas areas.
The analysis tools used in the study may be applicable elsewhere, but due to variations in weather, mosquito populations, and other factors, each region or county will need to conduct their own analysis to identify the most appropriate vector-index rating signaling when to act, Haley says. Along with the paper, the authors provide an instruction manual for other counties to calculate the vector index from their own mosquito infection surveillance data.
“Given the leading character of this index, epidemiologists and government officials can implement, in a more timely manner, preventative measures to reduce the impact of future West Nile Virus outbreaks,” said Dr. Tom Fomby, professor of economics in the Dedman College of Humanities and Sciences at Southern Methodist University, who contributed statistical methods more commonly used in economics to evaluate the vector index.
Other authors of the study were Wendy Chung, chief epidemiologist of Dallas County Health and Human Services, and DCHHS colleagues Christen Buseman, Sibeso Joyner, and Sonya Hughes; and James Luby, professor of internal medicine in the division of infectious diseases at UT Southwestern.
Source: UT Southwestern Medical Center