News
ICViewExpert PerspectivesMedical World NewsVideosWebinars
Conference CoverageConference ListingAPIC Chapters
Infection Control TodaySupplements And Featured Publications
CME/CEEditorial Advisory BoardJob BoardPartnersSponsoredWhitepapers
Subscribe
Educator of the Year Official Rules2024 Educator of the Year Winner2023 Educator of the Year WinnerEducator of the Year
Advanced TechnologyAdvanced TechnologyAdvanced Technology
Bug of the Month
COVID-19
Environmental ServicesEnvironmental Services
HAIs
Hand Hygiene
IC Trends
Long-Term CareLong-Term Care
Operating Room
Personal Protective EquipmentPersonal Protective Equipment
Policy
PreventionPreventionPreventionPrevention
Sterile ProcessingSterile Processing
Surface Disinfection
Vascular Access
Spotlight -
  • IC Trends
  • Bug of the Month
  • Featured Articles
  • Featured Columns
  • Pathogen Playbook
Advanced TechnologyAdvanced TechnologyAdvanced Technology
Bug of the Month
COVID-19
Environmental ServicesEnvironmental Services
HAIs
Hand Hygiene
IC Trends
Long-Term CareLong-Term Care
Operating Room
Personal Protective EquipmentPersonal Protective Equipment
Policy
PreventionPreventionPreventionPrevention
Sterile ProcessingSterile Processing
Surface Disinfection
Vascular Access
    • News
    • Subscribe
Advertisement

Expert Asks, Can HAI-Related Interventions Be 'Right-Sized?'

August 16, 2010
Article

A one-size-fits-all approach may not work for infection prevention and control efforts, says Kathryn B. Kirkland, MD, from the Section of Infectious Disease and International Health at Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center in Lebanon, N.H. In a commentary in the August issue of Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology, Kirkland acknowledges, "Determining which infection control interventions should be implemented in a given situation is a constant challenge for those who work in healthcare epidemiology. The literature overflows with papers detailing successful outcomes associated with numerous interventions applied in a range of settings to a variety of patient populations."

Kirkland says it should be "intuitively obvious" that not every intervention that seems to be successful should be implemented in every facility and that it could be disingenuous to assume that there is one "right size" that is a fit for all healthcare facilities. Kirkland advocates the importance of infection preventionists and healthcare epidemiologists being able to select from best practices as well as other interventions that could be considered to be "good practices, useful in some settings, unnecessary in others." She emphasizes that a better fit could be achieved if these professionals were able to customize their infection prevention and control programs, and that "which good practices to choose likely depends on local context."

Linking outcomes to intended interventions is a slippery slope, Kirkland suggests, noting, "Because infection prevention often involves a complex set of socio-behavioral interventions that are clearly dependent on the context in which they are implemented, studies that provide information about situations in which certain interventions do or do not work make up an important part of the evidence base." Kirkland suggests further that researchers "carefully measure the extent to which the intended interventions were actually impemented," and that they "provide enough detail about the context in which the interventions were implemented to allow others to judge the applicability in their own setting." Kirkland adds that it could be time to modify the existing categories used by guideline writers, such as those at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) to acknowledge "the importance of local context in determining which of the hundreds of infection prevention best practices should be implemented when."

Reference: Kirkland KB. From Best to Good: Can We "Right-Size" Approaches to Reducing Healthcare-Associated Infections? Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol 2010;31:784-785.

Recent Videos
Anna Castillo-Gutierrez, CRCST, CSPDT, CHL, CIS, CFER,  and Maya Luera, CRCST, CIS, CER, CHL
Lucy Witt, MD
Chase Elms, BS, CRCST
Garrett Hollembeak, CRCST, CIS, CHL, CER, CIC
Hannah Schroeder, BSHA, CRCST, CIS, CHL, CER,
Anthony Bondon CRCST, CHL, BSM, AAS, SME, LSSYB
Deannard Esnard, CRCST, CIS, CER, CHL, CFER, CQUIA
Kevin Bush, Jr, DHSc, EdD, MSHA, MA, MS, FACHE
Vatsala Rangachar Srinivasa, MPH
Sarah Vinson, MBA, CRCST
Related Content

Hot Topics in Infection Prevention With Saskia v. Popescu

Hot Topics in IPC for May 9, 2025: HICPAC, Measles, H5N1, and More

Saskia v. Popescu, PhD, MPH, MA, CIC, FAPIC
May 9th 2025
Article

This week’s Infection Control Today’s Hot Topics in IPC discusses the latest in the measles outbreak, H5N1 in cattle herds, HICPAC, and more.


CDC: HICPAC Silenced  (Adobe Stock)

The Disbanding of HICPAC: A Dangerous Silencing in the Fight Against Health Care-Associated Infections

Heather Stoltzfus, MPH, RN, CIC
May 8th 2025
Article

The abrupt disbanding of HICPAC silences decades of infection control expertise, leaving health care workers without unified guidance as deadly threats to patient safety rise.


Endoscopy at the hospital. Doctor holding endoscope before gastroscopy  (Adobe Stock by romaset)

Endoscopes and Lumened Instruments: New Studies Highlight Persistent Contamination Risks

Alexander Sundermann, DrPH, CIC, FAPIC
May 7th 2025
Article

Two new studies reveal troubling contamination in both new endoscopes and cleaned lumened surgical instruments, challenging the reliability of current reprocessing practices and manufacturer guidelines.


Policy: FY26 Discretionary Budget  (AI image created by author)

The Chopping Block: Administration’s FY26 Discretionary Budget Proposal Targets Public Health Lifelines

Brenna Doran, PhD, MA, ACC, CIC
May 5th 2025
Article

The proposed elimination of ASPR’s Hospital Preparedness Program in the 2026 federal budget could dismantle essential emergency readiness infrastructure and jeopardize national health care safety.


National Foundation for Infectious Diseases  (Image credit: NFID)

NFID 2025 Report Reveals Alarming Gaps in Hand Hygiene Practices Among US Adults

John Parkinson
May 5th 2025
Article

Clean Hospitals Corner With Alexandra Peters, PhD

Happy Hand Hygiene Day! Rethinking Glove Use for Safer, Cleaner, and More Ethical Health Care

Alexandra Peters, PhD
May 5th 2025
Article

Despite their protective role, gloves are often misused in health care settings—undermining hand hygiene, risking patient safety, and worsening environmental impact. Alexandra Peters, PhD, points out that this misuse deserves urgent attention, especially today, World Hand Hygiene Day.

Related Content

Hot Topics in Infection Prevention With Saskia v. Popescu

Hot Topics in IPC for May 9, 2025: HICPAC, Measles, H5N1, and More

Saskia v. Popescu, PhD, MPH, MA, CIC, FAPIC
May 9th 2025
Article

This week’s Infection Control Today’s Hot Topics in IPC discusses the latest in the measles outbreak, H5N1 in cattle herds, HICPAC, and more.


CDC: HICPAC Silenced  (Adobe Stock)

The Disbanding of HICPAC: A Dangerous Silencing in the Fight Against Health Care-Associated Infections

Heather Stoltzfus, MPH, RN, CIC
May 8th 2025
Article

The abrupt disbanding of HICPAC silences decades of infection control expertise, leaving health care workers without unified guidance as deadly threats to patient safety rise.


Endoscopy at the hospital. Doctor holding endoscope before gastroscopy  (Adobe Stock by romaset)

Endoscopes and Lumened Instruments: New Studies Highlight Persistent Contamination Risks

Alexander Sundermann, DrPH, CIC, FAPIC
May 7th 2025
Article

Two new studies reveal troubling contamination in both new endoscopes and cleaned lumened surgical instruments, challenging the reliability of current reprocessing practices and manufacturer guidelines.


Policy: FY26 Discretionary Budget  (AI image created by author)

The Chopping Block: Administration’s FY26 Discretionary Budget Proposal Targets Public Health Lifelines

Brenna Doran, PhD, MA, ACC, CIC
May 5th 2025
Article

The proposed elimination of ASPR’s Hospital Preparedness Program in the 2026 federal budget could dismantle essential emergency readiness infrastructure and jeopardize national health care safety.


National Foundation for Infectious Diseases  (Image credit: NFID)

NFID 2025 Report Reveals Alarming Gaps in Hand Hygiene Practices Among US Adults

John Parkinson
May 5th 2025
Article

Clean Hospitals Corner With Alexandra Peters, PhD

Happy Hand Hygiene Day! Rethinking Glove Use for Safer, Cleaner, and More Ethical Health Care

Alexandra Peters, PhD
May 5th 2025
Article

Despite their protective role, gloves are often misused in health care settings—undermining hand hygiene, risking patient safety, and worsening environmental impact. Alexandra Peters, PhD, points out that this misuse deserves urgent attention, especially today, World Hand Hygiene Day.

Advertise
About Us
Editorial Board
Contact Us
Job Board
Terms and Conditions
Privacy
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Contact Info

2 Commerce Drive
Cranbury, NJ 08512

609-716-7777

© 2025 MJH Life Sciences

All rights reserved.
Home
About Us
News