News
ICViewExpert PerspectivesMedical World NewsVideosWebinars
Conference CoverageConference ListingAPIC Chapters
Infection Control TodaySupplements And Featured Publications
CME/CEEditorial Advisory BoardJob BoardPartnersSponsoredWhitepapers
Subscribe
Educator of the Year Official Rules2024 Educator of the Year Winner2023 Educator of the Year WinnerEducator of the Year
Advanced TechnologyAdvanced TechnologyAdvanced Technology
Bug of the Month
COVID-19
Environmental ServicesEnvironmental Services
HAIs
Hand Hygiene
IC Trends
Long-Term CareLong-Term Care
Operating Room
Personal Protective EquipmentPersonal Protective Equipment
Policy
PreventionPreventionPreventionPrevention
Sterile ProcessingSterile Processing
Surface Disinfection
Vascular Access
Spotlight -
  • IC Trends
  • Bug of the Month
  • Featured Articles
  • Featured Columns
  • Pathogen Playbook
Advanced TechnologyAdvanced TechnologyAdvanced Technology
Bug of the Month
COVID-19
Environmental ServicesEnvironmental Services
HAIs
Hand Hygiene
IC Trends
Long-Term CareLong-Term Care
Operating Room
Personal Protective EquipmentPersonal Protective Equipment
Policy
PreventionPreventionPreventionPrevention
Sterile ProcessingSterile Processing
Surface Disinfection
Vascular Access
    • News
    • Subscribe
Advertisement

Differences in Attitudes Toward COVID-19 and Influenza Vaccines Revealed by Hesitancy Trends

January 3, 2024
By Saskia v. Popescu, PhD, MPH, MA, CIC, FAPIC
News
Article

Survey shows people think the influenza vaccine is safer than the COVID-19 vaccine. This is concerning as COVID-19 is more prevalent and hospitalizes more people. This could result in low vaccine uptake.

Health care worker holding a vaccine needle.  (Adobe Stock 410673389 by Aron M - Austria)

Health care worker holding a vaccine needle.

(Adobe Stock 410673389 by Aron M - Austria)

As we start 2024, it’s hard not to look back and consider our actions and responses to the public health COVID-19 crisis we’ve lived through over the last few years. Of the many things we continue to face in public health is how to improve vaccine uptake and attitudes towards these critical tools.

To begin, consider influenza and COVID-19 incidence rates in the United States this past year. There have been 7.1-14 million influenza illnesses, 3.2-6.5 million influenza (flu) medical visits, 73,000-150,000 flu hospitalizations, and 4500-13,000 deaths.1

According to the CDC, test positivity in the United States is 12.7%, and 2.5% of emergency department visits are diagnosed as COVID-19.

In the week before Christmas 2023, over 29,000 hospitalizations were due to COVID-19, underscoring the increase in disease transmission and severity.2 The CDC also reported over 7090 hospital admissions for influenza for the week that ended December 9, 2023, up from 5816 admissions the week ending December 2.

These statistics are concerning because both respiratory viruses are seeing an increase in incidence rates. According to a new survey, safety beliefs about COVID-19 vaccines may lead to lower immunization uptake, potentially exacerbating the problem.

Specifically, the survey was developed into a new research study published in JAMA, which assessed vaccine attitudes towards COVID-19 versus influenza.3 The authors take care to note that in the post-emergency pandemic state of COVID-19, attitudes have shifted and that ensuring adults continue to get vaccinated requires understanding various pieces, such as perception of annual vaccine schedules, coadministration, and communication.

Using data from a national survey of adults administered July 7 to 16, 2023, researchers could better understand attitudes towards these two vaccines. This survey looked at adult vaccine attitudes but differentiated in those 50 and older, as such individuals may have a higher risk for severe disease. The survey ultimately reached and returned results for 1430 adults (a 44% return rate), and attitudes included effectiveness and safety, vaccination intentions, and dug into hesitancy.

The authors of the study reported that respondents claimed that “nearly equal shares said that COVID-19 vaccines (42%) and influenza vaccines (40%) are very effective at protecting against serious illness or hospitalization (all percentages are weighted). Views diverged on vaccine safety, where a higher share said influenza vaccines are safer than COVID-19 vaccines (55% vs 41%). Similarly, intentions differed: 49% said they are very likely to get an influenza vaccine this season, compared with 36% saying the same for an updated COVID-19 vaccine. Patterns were similar among adults aged 50 years and older. Among more hesitant adults (less likely to get vaccinated), concerns about updated COVID-19 and influenza vaccines differed.”3

Hesitancy surrounded the COVID-19 vaccine more, with responses citing a need for more research, worries about safety and efficacy, and that there was already substantial individual immunity from previous infections or vaccination. Interestingly, individuals reported distrusting government agencies and vaccine development companies for COVID-19 despite the same being used to promote influenza shots.

Ultimately, there were many reasons for hesitancy, and this cross-sectional study shared some important, interesting, self-reported findings that can be used to drive more focused education. As we move further away from the COVID-19 emergency state, it will be important to address hesitancy and rebuild trust in science, policy, and response.

REFERENCES

1. 2023-2024 U.S. Flu Season: Preliminary In-Season Burden Estimates. CDC. Accessed December 29, 2023. https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden/preliminary-in-season-estimates.htm

2. COVID Data Tracker. CDC. Accessed December 23, 2023. https://covid.cdc.gov/covid-data-tracker/#datatracker-home

3. Steelfisher GK, Findling MG, Caporello HL, McGowan E, Espino L, Sutton J. Divergent Attitudes Toward COVID-19 Vaccine vs Influenza Vaccine. JAMA Netw Open. 2023;6(12):e2349881. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2023.49881

Recent Videos
Concept images of Far-UVC  (Adobe Stock 316993517 by hopenv)
Physicians Sound Alarm: Vaccine Misinformation and Policy Failures Threaten US Public Health
Anna Castillo-Gutierrez, CRCST, CSPDT, CHL, CIS, CFER,  and Maya Luera, CRCST, CIS, CER, CHL
Lucy Witt, MD
Chase Elms, BS, CRCST
Garrett Hollembeak, CRCST, CIS, CHL, CER, CIC
Hannah Schroeder, BSHA, CRCST, CIS, CHL, CER,
Anthony Bondon CRCST, CHL, BSM, AAS, SME, LSSYB
Deannard Esnard, CRCST, CIS, CER, CHL, CFER, CQUIA
Kevin Bush, Jr, DHSc, EdD, MSHA, MA, MS, FACHE
Related Content

Concept photo of a hospital worker doing cleaning in operation room  (Adobe Stock 248152636 by karrastock)

Optimizing Training for Environmental Services Staff: A Critical Component of Patient Safety and Infection Control

Tommy Davis, PhD
May 15th 2025
Article

A determined infection preventionist is walking into a busy facility.  (AI image created by author)

IP LifeLine: Resilience as an Ongoing Journey, Not a Destination

Brenna Doran, PhD, MA, ACC, CIC
May 15th 2025
Article

As infection prevention infrastructure unravels, professionals face déjà vu from the pandemic’s darkest days—making resilience not just important, but essential for survival and progress.


Simone Godwin, DVM, MPH, CIC

Non-tuberculous Mycobacterium Outbreak at Surgery Center Highlights Infection Control Lapses

Alexander Sundermann, DrPH, CIC, FAPIC
May 13th 2025
Article

A rare Tennessee outbreak of Mycobacterium fortuitum revealed deep gaps in infection prevention at outpatient surgery centers—where oversight, staffing, and reporting often fall short.


The disbanding of HICPAC  (Adobe Stock)

In the Wake of HICPAC: How APIC is Leading the Fight to Preserve National Infection Prevention Standards

Tori Whitacre Martonicz
May 13th 2025
Article

The disbanding of HICPAC has left infection prevention experts scrambling to preserve national standards and ensure continuity amid growing concern over science-driven public health policy. Connie Steed, MSN, RN, CIC, FAPIC, speaks with ICT.


Hot Topics in Infection Prevention With Saskia v. Popescu

Hot Topics in IPC for May 9, 2025: HICPAC, Measles, H5N1, and More

Saskia v. Popescu, PhD, MPH, MA, CIC, FAPIC
May 9th 2025
Article

This week’s Infection Control Today’s Hot Topics in IPC discusses the latest in the measles outbreak, H5N1 in cattle herds, HICPAC, and more.


CDC: HICPAC Silenced  (Adobe Stock)

The Disbanding of HICPAC: A Dangerous Silencing in the Fight Against Health Care-Associated Infections

Heather Stoltzfus, MPH, RN, CIC
May 8th 2025
Article

The abrupt disbanding of HICPAC silences decades of infection control expertise, leaving health care workers without unified guidance as deadly threats to patient safety rise.

Related Content

Concept photo of a hospital worker doing cleaning in operation room  (Adobe Stock 248152636 by karrastock)

Optimizing Training for Environmental Services Staff: A Critical Component of Patient Safety and Infection Control

Tommy Davis, PhD
May 15th 2025
Article

A determined infection preventionist is walking into a busy facility.  (AI image created by author)

IP LifeLine: Resilience as an Ongoing Journey, Not a Destination

Brenna Doran, PhD, MA, ACC, CIC
May 15th 2025
Article

As infection prevention infrastructure unravels, professionals face déjà vu from the pandemic’s darkest days—making resilience not just important, but essential for survival and progress.


Simone Godwin, DVM, MPH, CIC

Non-tuberculous Mycobacterium Outbreak at Surgery Center Highlights Infection Control Lapses

Alexander Sundermann, DrPH, CIC, FAPIC
May 13th 2025
Article

A rare Tennessee outbreak of Mycobacterium fortuitum revealed deep gaps in infection prevention at outpatient surgery centers—where oversight, staffing, and reporting often fall short.


The disbanding of HICPAC  (Adobe Stock)

In the Wake of HICPAC: How APIC is Leading the Fight to Preserve National Infection Prevention Standards

Tori Whitacre Martonicz
May 13th 2025
Article

The disbanding of HICPAC has left infection prevention experts scrambling to preserve national standards and ensure continuity amid growing concern over science-driven public health policy. Connie Steed, MSN, RN, CIC, FAPIC, speaks with ICT.


Hot Topics in Infection Prevention With Saskia v. Popescu

Hot Topics in IPC for May 9, 2025: HICPAC, Measles, H5N1, and More

Saskia v. Popescu, PhD, MPH, MA, CIC, FAPIC
May 9th 2025
Article

This week’s Infection Control Today’s Hot Topics in IPC discusses the latest in the measles outbreak, H5N1 in cattle herds, HICPAC, and more.


CDC: HICPAC Silenced  (Adobe Stock)

The Disbanding of HICPAC: A Dangerous Silencing in the Fight Against Health Care-Associated Infections

Heather Stoltzfus, MPH, RN, CIC
May 8th 2025
Article

The abrupt disbanding of HICPAC silences decades of infection control expertise, leaving health care workers without unified guidance as deadly threats to patient safety rise.

Advertise
About Us
Editorial Board
Contact Us
Job Board
Terms and Conditions
Privacy
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Contact Info

2 Commerce Drive
Cranbury, NJ 08512

609-716-7777

© 2025 MJH Life Sciences

All rights reserved.
Home
About Us
News