Preheated Skin Disinfection is Non-Inferior to Room-Temperature Disinfection in Bacterial Reduction

In clinical practice, patients who are awake often comment that cold surgical skin disinfectant is unpleasant. This is not only a problem of patients’ experience; heat loss during the disinfection process is a problem that can result in hypothermia. Wistrand et al. (2015) say that the evidence for the efficacy of preheated disinfection is scarce, and in their study, they tested whether preheated skin disinfectant was non-inferior to room-temperature skin disinfectant on reducing bacterial colonization during pacemaker implantation.

This randomized, controlled, non-inferiority trial included 220 patients allocated to skin disinfection with preheated (36 °C) or room-temperature (20 °C) chlorhexidine solution in 70 percent ethanol. Cultures were obtained by swabbing at four time-points: before skin disinfection (skin surface), after skin disinfection (skin surface), after the incision (subcutaneously in the wound), and before suturing (subcutaneously in the wound).

The researchers say that the absolute difference in growth between patients treated with preheated versus room-temperature skin disinfectant was zero (90 % CI −0.101 to 0.101; preheated: 30 of 105 [28.6 %] vs. room-temperature: 32 of 112 [28.6 %]). The pre-specified margin for statistical non-inferiority in the protocol was set at 10 % for the preheated disinfectant. There were no significant differences between groups regarding SSIs three month postoperatively, which occurred in 0.9 % (1 of 108) treated with preheated and 1.8 % (2 of 112) treated with room-temperature skin disinfectant.

The researchers concluded that preheated skin disinfection is non-inferior to room-temperature disinfection in bacterial reduction, and therefore suggest that preheated skin disinfection become routine in clean surgery. Their research was published in Antimicrobial Resistance and Infection Control

Reference: Camilla Wistrand C, Söderquist B, Magnusson A and Nilsson U. The effect of preheated versus room-temperature skin disinfection on bacterial colonization during pacemaker device implantation: a randomized controlled non-inferiority trial. Antimicrobial Resistance and Infection Control 2015, 4:44  doi:10.1186/s13756-015-0084-1