TB Report Finds a Breakdown at the Intersection of Homeland Security and Public Health

Article

WASHINGTON, D.C. -- Yesterday, at the request of Committee on Homeland Security Chairman Bennie G. Thompson (D-MS), the Majority Staff of the Committee on Homeland Security released a comprehensive report examining the government's difficulties in handling the XDR-TB case and the government's current capabilities to manage an incident such as this. The report, titled "XDR-TB 2007: A Breakdown at the Intersection of Homeland Security and Public Health," finds that many of the problems experienced during the Andrew Speaker case have still not been remedied.

In addition to providing a comprehensive timeline of events, the report explores the interactions between the Department of Homeland Security and the CDC regarding public health security issues, identifies weaknesses in homeland security processes designed to prevent persons of interest from entering into the U.S., and makes recommendations for improvements to better secure America.

Thompson issued the following statement with the release of the report: "This was a real world incident, and there was a breakdown at the intersection of homeland security and public health. The government has numerous plans and policies in place to secure our communities, but they just didn't follow the playbook. This certainly raises questions about our homeland security if the government had this much trouble countering TB, let alone countering terrorism."

The Homeland Security Subcommittee on Emerging Threats plans to examine public health and pandemic preparedness issues in a public hearing later this month.

Source: Committee on Homeland Security

Newsletter

Stay prepared and protected with Infection Control Today's newsletter, delivering essential updates, best practices, and expert insights for infection preventionists.

Recent Videos
David J. Weber, MD, MPH, president of the Society for Healthcare Epidemiology of America
Brenna Doran PhD, MA, hospital epidemiology and infection prevention for the University of California, San Francisco, and a coach and consultant of infection prevention; Jessica Swain, MBA, MLT, director of infection prevention and control for Dartmouth Health in Lebanon, New Hampshire; and Shanina Knighton, associate professor at Case Western Reserve University School of Nursing and senior nurse scientist at MetroHealth System in Cleveland, Ohio
Brenna Doran PhD, MA, hospital epidemiology and infection prevention for the University of California, San Francisco, and a coach and consultant of infection prevention; Jessica Swain, MBA, MLT, director of infection prevention and control for Dartmouth Health in Lebanon, New Hampshire; and Shanina Knighton, associate professor at Case Western Reserve University School of Nursing and senior nurse scientist at MetroHealth System in Cleveland, Ohio
© 2025 MJH Life Sciences

All rights reserved.